Pin It
Thursday, February 7th, 2013

Do Bilingual Children Know Fewer Words Than Monolinguals?

By
Do Bilingual Children Really Know Less Words than Monolinguals?/ © Shutterstock

Linguistic research in young bilingual children has focused on whether multilingual children develop language skills in the same way and at the same speed as monolingual children. Numerous studies in the field have focused on this question by examining different aspects of language, including grammar, vocabulary, pronunciation, etc.

 

A recent article from Diane Poulin-Dubois, Ellen Bialystok and their colleagues (2012), published in the International Journal of Bilingualism, looks at the area of vocabulary. Research has often shown that bilingual children produce their first word at about the same time as monolingual children, on average. But there is still more to be understood in this area. This study analyzes whether children exposed to two languages on a frequent basis access words in the brain and produce words in the same way as monolingual children. The children in their study were 24 months old at the time of testing.

 

They tested the children in several different ways. To begin with, they asked parents to document the linguistic environment (how many hours children are exposed to each language). Secondly, the toddlers’ parents were asked to fill out a checklist of what words their child says and understands. In the case of bilingual children, parents filled out two forms (one for each language). Finally, the toddlers were assessed using a computerized task. On a screen, two images were shown while the children heard a word. The toddlers had to touch the image matching the word they heard, in order to assess their word comprehension.

 

The results of the study showed that compared with monolinguals, the bilinguals have a smaller vocabulary if only one language is taken into account. Bilingual children are able to produce fewer words than their monolinguals counterparts at the same given age. This was not a new finding in the literature. However, when the bilingual’s two languages were taken into account (as they should be in my opinion), the bilinguals’ vocabulary was similar to that of monolinguals.

 

When it comes to comprehension, the study found no difference in the children’s scores. Both the bilingual and monolingual children accurately picked one image over the other and reacted to the sound cue at a similar speed. Bilingual toddlers therefore show no delay in word comprehension.

 

Another result of the study is the link between language exposure and word production. The experiments confirmed previous studies (David & Wei, 2008) demonstrating that the more a child is exposed to a language, the bigger their vocabulary in that language. For parents, it reinforces the idea that increasing your child’s exposure time to a language will almost invariably augment their language skills in that language (from a vocabulary point of view, at least).

 

Finally, Poulin-Dubois and her colleagues analyzed translation equivalents. Translation equivalents, a scientific way of naming synonyms across languages, are words that bilinguals share in both languages. For example, a French-English bilingual child may know the word ‘chien’ (dog in French) AND the word ‘dog’. The child has two words for one concept. The authors revealed that bilingual children with a large number of translation equivalents in their vocabulary responded faster to the computerized test than monolinguals, as they were able to understand and identify the word they heard quicker. This confirms that children who have two words for one concept are able to retrive that word more rapidly in the brain. Previous studies had suggested that having two words for one concept may inhibit a child’s performance. This study proves otherwise.

 

This study highlights that bilingual children are not delayed in any area of vocabulary when compared to monolingual children. Additionally, it encourages parents to create as rich an experience as possible for their multilingual children.

 

Poulin-Dubois, D., Bialystok, E., Blaye, A., Polonia, A. & Yott, J. (2012). Lexical access and vocabulary development in very young bilinguals, International Journal of Bilingualism.

David, A.  & Wei, L. (2008). Individual Differences in the Lexical Development of French-English Bilingual Children, International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 11, 5.

© 2013 – 2014, Annabelle Humanes. All rights reserved.

More Great Stuff You'll Love:


Circumcision Wars

She fought her Turkish in-laws on it--did she succeed?

How I Reclaimed My House from My Mother-in-Law

A whole year of arguing in the making

Birth, Loss and In Between

Life after devastation

Are Germans Really Rude?

This German dad shares his thoughts

ABOUT THE AUTHOR


Annabelle Humanes has been living in Germany with her Portuguese husband and daughter since 2011. Originally from France, she has previously lived in England for 13 years where she studied and worked as a researcher in language acquisition. She blogs about her multilingual family at thepiripirilexicon.com

Leave us a comment!

10 Comments
  1. Commentsanonymous   |  Thursday, 07 February 2013 at 10:58 am

    An article on linguistics would be easier to take seriously if it did not contain a grammatical error in the title. Should be “fewer” works, not “less”. Argh.

  2. CommentsThe Editors   |  Thursday, 07 February 2013 at 11:00 am

    Thanks! Sometimes the obvious things slip by our Editors too but there’s no excuse for that! Corrected.

  3. CommentsAnnika Bourgogne   |  Saturday, 09 February 2013 at 1:10 am

    A very good article on an important subject. Even monolingual people have different vocabularies depending on the experiences they have, their hobbies, their profession, etc. Similarly, bilingual children may learn new words in their two vocabularies at different times, but if the words are needed in both languages, they will learn them. We for example noticed that our oldest child knew quite a bit about gardening in French, having helped out her grandpa in France over the summer holidays. As our own garden is quite the jungle she obviously did not have the same experience at home, hence the temporary lack of vocabulary in Finnish (nothing some good dinner-table conversation can’t fix).

    I agree that sufficient exposure to both languages (especially to the minority language) helps. Promoting biliteracy and reading to children in both (or more) languages, is also a great way to fill in any gaps in vocabulary.

  4. CommentsAnnabelle   |  Saturday, 09 February 2013 at 4:58 pm

    Apologies about the mistake. I am not a native English speaker! Now corrected.

  5. CommentsWeek in Links for #BilingualKids — March 1 | SpanglishBaby™   |  Friday, 01 March 2013 at 9:27 am

    […] Do Bilingual Children Know Fewer Words Than Monolinguals? from InCultureParent — If you’re raising bilingual children, you’ve probably heard this question a lot. Here’s some great info to dispel this myth. […]

  6. CommentsADM   |  Thursday, 02 May 2013 at 9:26 am

    I am so glad I came across this article. Our kids are German – English bilingual, we live in the U.S.. The oldest is in Kindergarten and just got her IOWA test results back. She did very well over all but it was interesting to note that her vocabulary skills were well below all of her other skills. I was wondering if that is something common to bilingual kids? And I guess the answer is yes …

  7. CommentsAnnick De Houwer   |  Friday, 21 June 2013 at 4:29 am

    I just wanted to add that recent research by myself and colleagues in the US has found that young bilinguals actually are about 4 months AHEAD of monolinguals when you look at the number of words they understand. And for the number of words they speak we didn’t find any statistical differences. You’ll find the link to the original article in the ‘In the spotlight’ rubric on the ERBIS website (which is up and running but far from complete yet, sorry; http://www.erbis.org).

  8. CommentsTrilingual Mama   |  Monday, 03 March 2014 at 4:28 am

    This is a well written well documented article. Thanks Annabelle!

  9. CommentsTesting your baby’s language progress through play | Trilingual Mama   |  Monday, 03 March 2014 at 5:20 am

    […] Do Bilingual Children Know Less Words than Monolinguals? This study highlights that bilingual children are not delayed in any area of vocabulary when compared to monolingual children. […]

  10. CommentsTesting your baby's language progress through play - Trilingual Mama   |  Friday, 30 January 2015 at 4:32 am

    […] Do Bilingual Children Know Less Words than Monolinguals? This study highlights that bilingual children are not delayed in any area of vocabulary when compared to monolingual children. […]









Notify me of follow-up comments via e-mail.
Or leave your email address and click here to receive email notifications of new comments without leaving a comment yourself.

Get weekly updates right in your inbox so you don't miss out!



Why My African Feminist Mother Gave Me the Identity of My Father's Tribe

She gave me an identity so different from her own.

2 Children’s Books about Jamaica

Explore Jamaica with your child.

Costa Rica with Kids: Two Weeks of Family Travel

Two weeks of Pura Vida in a country with so much to offer families.

Should I Worry about My Child's Accent in Her Foreign Language?

See why Dr. Gupta takes offense to this question and where children learn accents from

How to raise trilingual kids when exposure to Dad's language is limited

My kids only get 1-2 hours of the minority language per day-help!

What Cultural Norms Around Bare Feet Taught This Mother in Guatemala

Her baby's bare feet ended up being a lesson on poverty and privilege.

Why We Need to Read Multicultural Children's Books

Children need to see the world around them reflected in books.
[…] ben die daar zo over denkt, werd mij laatst op Facebook weer bevestigt. Daar kwam ik het bericht ‘Waarom Afrikaanse kinderen niet huilen’  (Engels) […...
From Why African Babies Don’t Cry
[…] potty.  I guess I remember always hearing (especially when I went through a time reading about Elimination Communication and early potty training when the Girl was small) that children f...
From Thanks to Chinese Potty-Training We’re Done With Diapers at 19 Months
I took a class called Psychology from an African Perspective and it talked about the African perspective on time. I love it. We are exactly where we are supposed to be and at the right time. I would...
From Why African Time is Best for Children
I luv your blog and look forward to reading more. I have an African child and want to raise him in his Father's culture. It is definitely NOT as easy as I thought it would b...
From 10 Tips on Living with Chronic Illness
Sorry * none at a...
From Why African Babies Don’t Cry
I know this is a very old article but I had to chime in. Mom's mental health matters also. It matters ALOT! I could never keep up with a schedule like this woman did. To each their own. I tried to B...
From Why African Babies Don’t Cry
This was a lovely write-up. I stopped when my kid was one. Breast milk had become an evening snack by 9 months and then, he just forgot. Two days in a row he went off to play with his cousins, and t...
From Breastfeeding in the Land of Genghis Khan
[…] This is a link to one of my favourite articles on breastfeeding, and here is my favourite breastfeeding photo of Kaylee and I. […...
From Breastfeeding in the Land of Genghis Khan
[…] How I Talk to my Classroom about Race by Madeleine Rogin […...
From How I Talk to My Kindergarten Classroom About Race

More Raising Bilingual Children