The topic of race is too often reduced to encouraging our children to ignore the racial differences around them, with the idea that this will result in creating a “colorblind” child who is more inclusive in her ability to see beyond color. There’s nothing wrong with wanting our children to look beneath the surface. That’s why we say things like “don’t judge a book by its cover” and “it’s what’s on the inside that really matters.”
But when we jump to this teaching before we have answered the many questions our children have about differences, and before we’ve taught them skills and strategies to combat racism, we have not adequately prepared them to be truly inclusive, especially as they will pick up on biased messages from the media as they grow. In order to promote inclusivity, we would do better to give our children a basic understanding about skin color differences and the value that being in a diverse community has for all of us. In this sense, becoming colorblind is not the ultimate goal. The real objective is recognizing, appreciating and understanding differences within the larger context of building inclusive communities.
The following is a developmental guide to talking about race for ages three to eight. I write this from the perspective of being a white kindergarten teacher and mother of two biracial daughters. I’ve thought a lot about how to lead developmentally appropriate conversations about race with my students and my children, and what it means to be white in the context of talking about race. This article also comes out of conversations I’ve had with other white parents, who have voiced their questions about what is developmentally appropriate to talk about with young children, and expressed their discomfort when their child says something about a racial difference in public. This guide is geared toward:
- Answering questions about what is developmentally appropriate by age in talking about race
- Providing a framework for a rich and interesting conversation around race, without discomfort or embarrassment, especially when children point out differences.
Teaching Race to 3-4 Year Olds
At this age children are full of curiosity about the world around them and begin to try to make sense of new and exciting environments like school. What a great time to begin a conversation about race and skin color! Read picture books that celebrate all the different shades we come in.
Some of my favorite books are:
“The Skin You Live in” by Michael Tyler
“All the Colors of the Earth” by Sheila Hamanaka
and “Skin Again”
A fun activity around skin color is to gather various shades of paint, including white, peach, different browns, etc. and mix paints together to find your child’s—and your—skin tone. You can use this paint to make artwork together. Most important, celebrate the diversity of skin tones in your own family, your larger community and the world while stressing the importance of not using these differences to put each other down.
Teaching Race to 5-6 Year Olds
At this age, the conversation around skin color/race can become even more rich and interesting as children begin to voice their questions about why we are the way we are and how we got our skin colors. Answer their questions!
Book Recommendations on Skin Color
Read books to your child that give a more scientific explanation of melanin and where skin colors come from. The best one I’ve found for this age group is “All the Colors We Are” by Katie Kissinger.
Products from Amazon.com
This is also the time to clear up any confusion your child may have about race. One of my white kindergarten students once told me that his mother was black. What he was trying to say was that she was tan, but he needed help figuring out those categories and what they mean.
Provide Children with Tools to be Inclusive
Five and six is also the age to give children language they can use to be inclusive with one another. For example, I often observe white kindergarteners being fascinated with the hair of African-American students, especially girls, and wanting to touch their hair. This is a problem for the African-American students, and for their parents, who did not necessarily want hands in their children’s hair every day. In my class, we had class meetings about the importance of giving our classmates personal space. But the conversation didn’t stop there. We also read books about different hair types, in order to teach about why we have different hair and why it’s important to appreciate this difference. A few good books are “Hair Dance!” by Dinah Johnson, Hair Like Mine and I Love My Hair.
Products from Amazon.com‹ ›
Another great resource for reinforcing the beauty of all different types of hair is the Sesame Street video, “I Love My Hair.”
<iframe width=”560″ height=”315″ src=”https://www.youtube.com/embed/enpFde5rgmw” frameborder=”0″ allow=”accelerometer; autoplay; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture” allowfullscreen></iframe>
Talk with Children about Racism
It is also important to talk explicitly with your child about racism, in order to help them recognize bias and racism when its occurs—either in their own lives or in the media. Your five or six year old will probably learn about the story of Martin Luther King Jr. and the Civil Rights movement this year, if she doesn’t know about it already. This is an important time to stress the dangers of excluding others because of race.
Use puppets to act out scenarios of exclusion around skin color and engage your child as a problem solver to come up with inclusive solutions. Also, connect the story of Dr. King to someone your child knows who works to stand up for a community and make positive change. This will help your child make sense of the story and of the larger themes around social justice and working toward peaceful change. You can also read children’s books that have “changemakers” in them. “The Lorax” by Dr. Seussis a good one!
Teaching Race to 7-8 Year Olds
At this age, children should have a basic understanding of where skin color comes from, how to be inclusive with one another around skin color differences and how to recognize bias or racism when they see it. If they don’t have this basic understanding, go back to the section on 3-4 year olds and begin there! It’s OK to start at square one in the conversation about race, even with an older child. Think of it as how you might assist your child in gaining a basic understanding of math in order to be prepared for higher math classes. There’s no shame in “skilling up” in any important learning area, whether it be math or learning about race, racism and empathy.
Watch Media and Read Books Featuring Children of Color
Along with continuing the work of appreciating the beauty of all races, through open dialogue about the importance of diversity in your school and/or neighborhood, it is critical to seek out media that features main characters of color. Help your child find books to read that feature characters of all different races, and not just the books that tell stories around racism, though those are important too. It is essential that your child sees characters of all races in “every day” books, experiencing relatable problems and situations. This will expand your child’s ability to empathize with all different kinds of people. As children get older and begin to pay attention to, and receive more messages about people of color in TV shows, advertisements and movies that are not always positive or affirming, this basis you created will become especially important.
Products from Amazon.com
Price: $6.99Was: $7.99
Price: $7.48Was: $7.99
Price: $7.19Was: $7.99
Price: $12.29Was: $17.99
In the conversation about race with slightly older children, we can discuss more strategies around how to be anti-racists. It is key to talk openly about how to be an ally, rather than a bystander, when it comes to viewing racism. Talk about “what if it’s not me”—what do you do if it’s not you that’s the victim of prejudice.
Teach your child about key anti-racists from the Civil Rights movement of all different races, such as those who are not often talked about, like Bob Moses, Myles Horton, Diane Nash and Fannie Lou Hamer.
Find people in your own family or community who work to solve problems. Talk about how change happens when many people work together to fight against injustices. Ask your child what problems they see in their community and find ways to take action together, through community service, church groups, volunteering, etc. Continue to create space for your child to ask their growing questions about race and racism. And if you don’t know the answers or how to respond, it’s OK to say, “I need to think about that and get back to you’” and then do some reading to expand your own knowledge. Here are some books that have helped me: White Like Me by Tim Wise, Why are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria by Beverly Daniel Tatum, I’m Chocolate, You’re Vanilla: Raising Healthy Black and Biracial Children in a Race-Conscious World by Marguerite A. Wright and Nurture Shock by Po Bronson.
Products from Amazon.com
I'm Chocolate, You're Vanilla: Raising Healthy Black and Biracial Children in a Race-Conscious WorldPrice: $12.63Was: $18.95
Price: $11.75Was: $14.95
Price: $12.62Was: $16.00
More Fun Activities To Do around Race/ Skin Color
- Go to a paint store and get all different colors of paint chips. Have your child compare her skin to the paint chips and use these names as inspiration for poetry or artwork.
- Use the book “Tan to Tamarind” by Malathi Michelle Iyengar to explore poems about the color brown, a color often left out of children’s poetry and songs. After reading the poems, use brown spices such as cinnamon, cloves, coffee grounds and nutmeg to make art. Write poems about how these spices feel and smell. The result is a collection of beautiful associations with the color brown.
- Encourage your child to add skin colors to their drawings of people and especially on their own self-portraits. You can purchase skin color pencils and crayons at most art stores. A great book to read before drawing a self-portrait or having your child draw one is “The Colors of Us” Jazz, “In this country American means white. Everyone else has to hyphenate.” by Karen Katz. The attention given to the idea that everyone has a skin color, not only people of color, will work to build your child’s understanding of race and the importance of being inclusive. It will also work against any tendency white children have to view their skin as “colorless,” which can be dangerous in the context of our shared history around racism, where being white was often seen as being just “American,” or as Toni Morrison writes in
Originally published in 2014.